A quick note before we start. ALIGNED: The Inside Out Path to Coaching Excellence has been out for three weeks. Thank you to every coach who has grabbed a copy, shared it, or sent a note. If you still want one before the season gets too deep, you can find it here.
Now on to this week.
| What's your biggest challenge right now? (Click one and I'll send something to help you out.) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
For me, the hardest loss of the season is always the first one. Especially if it happened in our first few games.
The first loss has carried so much power for me throughout my coaching career. It led to rumination and second-guessing my roster, tactics, and the team's ceiling.
I let it carry too much power. Maybe you can relate.
Early in my career, my response to our first loss was always similar. To quote Vince Vaughan's character from Wedding Crashers, "I would take a turn to negative town." It led to a full-fledged crash out. Not a public one; I didn't flip chairs or yell, but an inner crash out. Long van rides home, questioning every planning decision I had made. Our offensive sets, defensive philosophy, what team gear we were ordering. All of it. I wasn't at my best, for sure.
The honest reason was that I wasn't comfortable enough with who I was as a coach, and I felt that the scoreboard threatened to expose me as a fraud.
I also felt profound disappointment because it didn't go the way I had envisioned when I excitedly planned the season months ago.
Every coach knows this moment. The scoreboard that disagrees with what you envisioned. The drive home where the loop in your head picks apart the play you drew up until two in the morning.
The loss itself is not what matters. It sucks, but losses happen.
What matters isn't the story on the scoreboard; it's the seventy-two hours that follow.
I have watched good programs overreact and lose a season in the three days after their first loss. I have watched middle-of-the-pack programs find a new level in the three days after theirs. The difference is almost never talent. It is what the head coach does in a specific window most coaches don't know exists.
The three windows
The seventy-two hours after a first loss break down into three distinct windows. Each one has a specific job. Each can be managed well or badly, and the second two are made harder by the first's mistakes.
Window 1 — The Walk-Off (0 to 60 minutes)
What you say in the handshake line, when you walk off the floor, the locker room, and the first ten minutes after the game.
This is the window most coaches handle worst. Emotions are hot. Fatigue is deep. The loss feels like confirmation of every nagging fear you had about this team coming in. The temptation is to lecture, to pick apart, to name individuals, to give the speech that makes you feel better about the coach you want to be seen as.
Don't give in to the temptation
The job in Window 1 is one sentence: name the feeling, choose the response.
Something like: “That hurt. The way we respond to it is what this season is actually about. We will look at it together on Monday. Tonight, go home.”
That is it. No lecture. No blame. No analysis. Your players do not need you to teach them in Window 1. They need you to anchor them in it.
This was the one spot I handled relatively well as a young coach.
Window 2 — The Next Day (24 to 36 hours)
The window between emotional reaction and practical response.
By the next morning, the heat has come off. You have slept, badly perhaps. The loop in your head has stopped running the game on repeat. You can think. It is really important to be clear-eyed in this moment. The natural instinct is to overreact. The reality is that it was one game.
This is when you do your real coaching work. Not with the team. On yourself.
Three questions to sit with, in order, before you look at any film:
- What happened out there that was about me, not about them? Not a quarter. A specific decision. A specific moment I owned.
- What happened that was about the system, not the effort? Where did my preparation fail them before they ever took the floor?
- What am I tempted to make this loss mean about this team that it does not actually mean?
The first question is the hardest. Most coaches skip it. The ones who do the real work get through it in forty-five minutes and come out with one specific thing to fix in themselves.
Sometimes the first loss reveals a flaw you remedy with a week of training. Others reveal something deeper that potentially requires changes to the larger season plan.
Window 3 — First Practice of the week (48 to 72 hours)
The practice after the first loss is the most important practice of your season. Not because of what you install. Because of what you model. Your athletes have been reading you since Window 1 for what the loss meant. By the start of that practice, they have decided. Your job in that practice is to calmly address what went wrong in your loss
Three moves for that practice:
Start with the truth. Name what the loss revealed. Not individually. About your squad as a whole. About your standards, preparation, and response. Five sentences, maximum.
Then stop talking about it. Run a practice that is sharper, not longer. Higher standards, not angrier. Energy up, volume down. The practice itself says what you need to say about the loss.
Finish with forward. Close practice with one specific thing you saw today that would have changed Saturday.
I've only made it to Christmas without a loss in only two of my 25 years. Most seasons our first loss was in the first two weeks. After my first few seasons, I intentionally scheduled a difficult opponent or tournament to reveal where we needed to grow.
One season early in my career stands out. We travelled six hours for a season-opening tournament, and it did not go well. Expectations were high because we returned 8 seniors. The tournament went poorly; in each game, we performed far below expectations in every game. We lost all three games, and I didn't handle it well. I totally lost it on my athletes at halftime of the third game. My insecurity boiled over, and I took it out on my players. I said things I didn't mean and couldn't take back.
It didn't totally destroy the season, but it took months to undo the damage I did that day. I damaged relationships that, in some cases, took years to repair.
I remember a very long, quiet drive home. I spent most of it ruminating about how poorly I handled myself.
It was a powerful lesson, but it was costly
The bigger pattern
The three windows apply to the first loss. They also apply to every loss after it. The reason the first one matters so much is that it sets the template. Whatever you do in the seventy-two hours after your first loss is what your team learns to expect every time it happens again.
Which is the real question this week.
What template are you about to set?
What is yours?
P.S. Hit reply and tell me what you did after your first loss of this season, or the one from a year you still think about. The patterns across coaches are useful, and I write back to everyone.
Podcast Episode of the Week
This week's podcast episode is my guest appearance on the Canada Basketball Coaching Podcast. I enjoyed the opportunity to talk about coaching with one of the best minds in Coaching, Mike MacKay. I hope it helps you out
How can I help you?
I help coaches build high performance.
As a Certified Mental Performance Consultant and basketball coach with 25+ years of experience, I understand the barriers to peak performance for both you and your athletes.
I would love to help you or your team build a competitive advantage.
Here are a few ways I can help:
- Consult with your team or coaching staff
- Teach mental skills to your team via Zoom
- Work 1-on-1 with coaches
- Work 1-on-1 with athletes
Book a Free Discovery Call
If you’re feeling the weight of expectations, pressure, or burnout, you don’t have to figure this out alone.
A discovery call is a chance to talk through your season, your goals, and your process with another coach who’s been there. No pitch. No obligation. Just a meaningful conversation.
Schedule a discovery call here.
Shoot me an email at jasonpayne@evolutionmpc.com. I love talking about coaching and seeing how I can help you.
Coaching is hard; let's make it easier.
Have A Great Weekend.